Home improvement projects come with plenty of questions. Homeowners want to know how contractors manage schedules, whether they’ll receive help choosing materials, what warning signs they should watch for, and what really happens behind the scenes.
In episode 58 of Under Construction: Renovating a Home, Redeeming an Industry, Erik and Tanya answered listener questions. The conversation covered everything from favorite exterior projects to the evolution of their working relationship, but each answer pointed back to the same idea: A successful renovation depends on trust, communication, and genuine care for the people involved.
Here are a few takeaways from the episode.
Your Project Matters, Even When Schedules Change

When you hire a contractor, it’s natural to feel like your project should become that company’s only priority. Your home is important to you, and you deserve to feel like it’s important to the people working on it.
At the same time, contractors typically juggle multiple homeowners, crews, and project timelines. Tanya explained that while every customer receives the team’s full attention during the time of their project, that timeline may shift as projects move through each phase or there are delays in the project.
Exterior construction schedules can change quickly, especially in Wisconsin. Weather may delay an installation, a current project may uncover unexpected damage, or a major storm may suddenly create urgent needs throughout the community. Sometimes supply chain challenges cause delays, like when materials aren’t ready on the manufacturer’s end or materials are unavailable across the board. These shifts don’t mean your contractor has forgotten about you, but they should be communicated clearly.
A trustworthy contractor will set realistic expectations and keep you informed when something changes. Learn more about the factors that affect project costs and schedules in our guide to transparency in contracting.
Pay Attention Before the Work Begins

One of the biggest red flags we often see happens before a contract is ever signed: a contractor fails to do what they said they would do. Maybe someone says they will call by the end of the week, but the call never comes, or they schedule an appointment and don’t show up or explain what happened. One missed call doesn’t automatically mean a contractor can’t be trusted, but their response tells you a lot about how they handle responsibility.
If the contractor acknowledges the mistake, offers a sincere apology, and follows through, the relationship may be easy to repair. If they avoid the conversation or repeatedly make promises they don’t keep, that pattern deserves attention.
As Erik explained in the podcast, “I do not want to ruin a good apology with an excuse.”
That philosophy matters throughout a renovation. Construction involves people, and humans occasionally make mistakes. What separates a trustworthy contractor is their willingness to communicate, take responsibility, and make the situation right. We shared more about that standard in our blog, What Happens When a Contractor Makes a Mistake?.
A Good Contractor Helps You Make Decisions

Some homeowners begin a renovation with an exact vision. They know the color, product, and overall look they want, and they need a contractor who can implement those choices well.
Other homeowners know they want a change but have no idea where to begin. For example, they may want a brown roof, without realizing how many variations of brown are available or how differently each option could look against their siding.
A good contractor can support both types of homeowners. The goal isn’t to take control of the design, but to offer enough knowledge and context for the homeowner to make a confident decision.
Our team regularly helps homeowners compare roofing and siding colors, but we’re also happy to support a project where someone arrives with a clear design vision. Samples, past project photos, and honest conversations about how materials work together can make an overwhelming decision feel much more manageable.
Different Perspectives Can Strengthen a Project

In episode 58, Erik and Tanya also answered a question many listeners have probably wondered: Do they ever disagree?
The short answer is yes. They may see a logistical decision differently or approach a problem from different perspectives. Erik brings decades of hands-on roofing and construction experience, while Tanya views the situation through the lens of operations and the homeowner relationships.
Those differences can create productive conversations. Both shared that they have learned to listen to the other person, think through the feedback, and change their minds when another approach makes more sense.
Homeowners actually benefit when a contractor’s team can respectfully challenge ideas behind the scenes. Multiple perspectives can uncover potential problems, improve a plan, and help the team find a stronger solution before the issue reaches the homeowner.
What Should You Look for in a Contractor?
Before hiring someone to work on your home, pay attention to more than the final number on the quote. Consider what their behavior tells you about the experience you’re likely to have.
Ask yourself:
- Did they follow through on their early commitments?
- Did they communicate clearly when something changed?
- Are they willing to explain materials, timelines, and potential challenges?
- Do they offer guidance without pressuring you?
- How do they respond when they make a mistake?
- Do you feel like they genuinely care about you and your home?
A renovation is ultimately a relationship between people. Experience and technical skill matter, but so do honesty, communication, and accountability.
At Big Fish Contracting, we want homeowners to feel supported from the first conversation through the final walkthrough. If you have questions about a roofing, siding, window, or remodeling project, contact our team to start an honest conversation about your home.











