At Big Fish Contracting, we do remodels all the time, so we’re familiar with the ins and outs of the project. But for many homeowners, this is something they’ll only experience a handful of times at most, so it’s natural to have questions about the process, what it involves, and what to expect.
In episode 53 of the Under Construction: Renovating a Home, Redeeming an Industry podcast, Erik and Kelsey sit down with homeowners Kristen and Tony, who are in the middle of adding a full mother-in-law suite and completely transforming the exterior of their home.
Every remodeling project has a construction side. There are plans, permits, materials, timelines, decisions, and dozens of details most homeowners never fully see.
But every remodeling project also has a human side. There’s the family living through the work, the reasons behind the project, and, of course, the emotions, expectations, surprises, and relationships that form along the way.
For Kristen and Tony Ludtke, their remodel started with a deeply personal need: Kristen’s mom had been diagnosed with dementia, and the couple began looking for a new home that could comfortably fit their family and allow them to care for her. After searching, they realized they didn’t want to leave the neighborhood and community they loved. Instead, they decided to stay and build an addition onto their existing home.
Choosing the Right Contractor

Before selecting Big Fish Contracting, Kristen and Tony did their homework. They received more than a dozen quotes for the project, and those numbers varied widely. Some were so low that they questioned whether the work could truly meet their expectations. Others were so high that building or buying a new house seemed like it would make more sense.
Price mattered, but it wasn’t the only factor to consider. Kristen and Tony also looked at reputation, reviews, referrals, and the way the team approached the first walkthrough. When Kevin from Big Fish came to the house and began discussing the project, something clicked. As Tony put it during the podcast, “It just felt right.”
That feeling matters, especially when a project is this personal and this involved. A major remodel means inviting a team into your home, your decisions, and sometimes, your hardest seasons of life. The right contractor must be able to complete the work, but they also have to be the kind of people you trust to walk alongside you through the process.
A Project with a Purpose
The original intent of the addition was to create a space for Kristen’s mom. Sadly, Kristen’s mom passed away just a week after the Big Fish team broke ground.
At that point, Kristen and Tony had to decide whether to continue. They could have stopped the project, but they knew the space still had meaning and potential for the future. Most importantly, the space still felt connected to Kristen’s mom.
Kristen shared that she often cries when she thinks about the addition, not only because of the grief behind it, but because of the gratitude. She talked about the sacrifices her mom made throughout her life and how those sacrifices helped make a project like this possible.
That is something easy to miss when we only look at a remodel through before-and-after photos. A room isn’t always just four walls. Sometimes, it represents legacy, family, and the desire to build something meaningful out of a difficult season.
Living Through Construction

There is a significant difference between remodeling a space and living in the home while that remodel is happening. The Ludtkes were experiencing it every day with three young daughters, a busy household, and crews working in and around their home.
That can be a lot. There is noise, dirt, decisions, and disruption. Even when a project is going well, construction changes the rhythm of everyday life.
For the Ludtkes, though, the team became part of the daily routine in a surprisingly positive way. Kristen shared that some days were hard, but having the carpenters around often helped keep her mind off things. The team was friendly, present, and easy to talk to. Her daughters became invested in the project too, wanting to see what was happening and getting to know the people working on their home.
Typically, homeowners and their families are counting down the days until the project wraps up and they get to enjoy their space. Meanwhile, the Ludtke girls may be among the few who will be genuinely sad when the project is finished. They have followed the action closely, created art projects in Tyler’s trailer, and made the team part of their world in the way only kids can. (If you haven’t seen them interview the crew yet, it’s a must-watch!)
For Big Fish, that kind of relationship is special. The work is still the work, but when you are in someone’s home for months, you’re also part of their life for that season.
The Surprises Behind the Walls

Every remodel comes with unknowns. Even when plans are detailed and expectations are clear, some questions you can’t answer until the work begins.
For the Ludtkes, one of the biggest concerns was what the team might find once the original siding was removed. Their home was built in the 1990s, and they worried there could be hidden damage or bigger issues beneath the surface. Fortunately, the team only found a couple of rotten areas, rather than a major problem.
Those unknowns felt especially real because the Ludtkes had dealt with water issues in the past, including a basement issue after heavy rain and a plumbing problem that caused water to drip into the kitchen. In both cases, the Big Fish team responded quickly. Kelsey and the crew helped remove carpet and move furniture to prevent mold issues, while Kevin connected them with a plumber during the pre-construction phase.
Those moments matter because they demonstrate what support looks like before and during a remodel, especially when something unexpected happens and homeowners aren’t sure what to do next.
The Permitting and Municipality Side
One of the biggest surprises for Tony and Kristen was the town board process. Since this was their first major home renovation project, they didn’t realize how involved some of the approval steps would be.
This is a side of remodeling many homeowners don’t consider until they are in it. Municipalities can vary significantly, even between nearby towns and villages. What’s straightforward in one community may be more complicated in another.
That’s one reason having an involved project manager is so valuable. Kelsey attended board meetings with the Ludtkes and helped them navigate a process that would have felt overwhelming on their own.
The Details That Made the Biggest Difference

While the addition itself was the largest part of the project, some of the most exciting changes came through the details. Kristen was especially excited about the new siding, windows, mudroom, and extra space. The new prep kitchen area will be a huge benefit for a family that loves hosting holidays, cooking for loved ones, and gathering with friends.
The windows were another favorite. Once the windows were installed, the Ludtkes noticed an immediate difference in comfort and temperature.
They also added a light in the front foyer closet while the electrician was already there. It was a small change, but one that made the home more functional. Those are the kinds of decisions that make sense during a remodel. If walls are open, trades are on-site, or systems are already being updated, it can be the perfect time to improve the little things that have bothered you for years.
More Than a Project

From Big Fish’s perspective, the Ludtke remodel has been meaningful because it represents what the company hopes construction can be. Yes, it is about quality work, solving problems, and creating a finished space that functions well for the family. But more importantly, it’s about relationships.
Kelsey shared that this project was unique because everyone involved experienced real life together. There were highs and lows, personal milestones, hard days, exciting progress, and moments of connection that turned a contractor-homeowner relationship into something more like friendship.
For homeowners considering a remodel, the Ludtkes’ experience is a reminder that the people you choose matter as much as the plans you approve. You’re deciding who will be in your home, who will answer when something unexpected happens, and who will help carry the project from idea to completion.
Thinking About Your Own Remodel?

A successful remodel starts with understanding what you need, what matters most to your family, and what kind of team you want beside you throughout the process.
Whether you’re planning an addition, updating your exterior, replacing windows, creating more functional living space, or preparing your home for the next season of life, Big Fish Contracting is here to help you think through every side of the experience.
At the end of the day, a remodel is never just about the house. It is about the people who live there, the memories they are making, and the future they are building one decision at a time.
Learn more about the Ludtkes and their home remodel in episode 53 of the Under Construction podcast or request a quote for your project.











