Experience can make you more confident in what you know. It can also make you more willing to admit when your thinking needs to change.

After more than two decades in construction, we’ve developed strong convictions about craftsmanship, leadership, and the responsibility that comes with working on someone’s home. Some of those beliefs have only grown stronger. Others have evolved as our team, services, and understanding of people have grown.

In episode 55 of the Under Construction Podcast, Erik and Tanya sat down to chat through some of those concepts they’ve changed their minds about over the course of their careers.

Changing your mind does not always mean abandoning your values. Sometimes, it means finding a better way to live them out.

Our Values Haven’t Changed

Honesty and integrity have been part of Big Fish since the beginning. They’ve been shaped through everyday decisions, including the ones no customer would ever see.

Years ago, Erik purchased roofing materials from Home Depot and realized after arriving at the jobsite that he had not been charged for several hundred dollars’ worth of ice and water shield. Money was tight, and keeping quiet would have been easy. Instead, he returned to the store and paid for it.

That decision didn’t win an award or lead directly to a new project. It simply reflected the kind of company Erik wanted to build. Doing the right thing matters most when it is inconvenient, and those small choices eventually become the foundation of a business.

Today, the company is larger, but the commitment remains the same. Honesty, communication, trust, humility, and service continue to guide how we work with homeowners, employees, and partners.

We Changed How We Think About Hiring

In the early years, technical experience carried a lot of weight when evaluating a potential employee. A strong résumé and years of construction experience could make someone appear to be an obvious fit.

Today, experience still matters, especially in an industry where installation quality directly affects a home’s safety and longevity. However, we’ve learned that skill alone doesn’t determine if someone is a good fit for the team. As Erik explained, “If you’re not the right person, it doesn’t matter what your skill set is.” 

Character matters just as much, and often more than technical skills. Someone with integrity, humility, and a strong work ethic can often learn the technical side of the job. This shift has made us more thoughtful about who joins Big Fish and how we support their growth. We’re building a team of people who can trust one another and represent the company well in a homeowner’s space.

We Learned That Expertise and Teaching Are Different Skills

When Big Fish was smaller, training often happened shoulder to shoulder. Erik could work alongside a new employee, demonstrate a technique, answer questions, and correct mistakes in real time.

As the company grew, that approach became harder to maintain. It also revealed an important lesson: being excellent at a job doesn’t automatically make someone excellent at teaching it.

A skilled carpenter may complete a task almost instinctively but struggle to explain each step to a beginner. An experienced project manager may be able to navigate a complex situation without knowing how to transfer that judgment to someone else. Teaching, coaching, and leadership are separate skills that must also be recognized and developed.

That realization has influenced how we assign responsibilities and develop our team. We want people working in roles that fit their strengths instead of assuming every high performer should follow the same path.

We See Workplace Culture Differently

For many people, work was once viewed as a straightforward exchange. You showed up, did your job, received a paycheck, and went home.

Employees today often want something more. They want to feel appreciated, connected to their coworkers, and part of work that has a larger purpose. Earlier in his career, Erik may have viewed some of those expectations as signs that younger generations were overly sensitive.

Over time, Erik came to recognize that this desire is not unique to one generation. “We want this community. We want this sense of belonging. We want to be a part of something bigger than ourselves.”

That doesn’t mean removing accountability or lowering standards. It means recognizing that people are not interchangeable labor. A strong culture makes room for differences while keeping everyone aligned around shared expectations. It also helps explain why our mission of renovating homes and redeeming an industry is about more than the finished project.

We Became More Open to Homeowner Preferences

Contractors naturally develop product preferences. After years of seeing how materials perform in Wisconsin weather, we have informed opinions about what we trust for roofing, siding, and full exterior renovations.

For a long time, those preferences led Big Fish to focus heavily on specific manufacturers and product lines. We still believe in recommending materials we know can perform well, but we have become more open to offering additional options when they fit a homeowner’s priorities and meet our installation standards.

A homeowner may arrive with a specific shingle or siding manufacturer in mind. Our job is to explain the differences, identify tradeoffs, and help the homeowner make an informed decision. That is now a larger part of our process. Professional expertise should guide homeowners, not take their voice out of the project.

Growth Has Made Us More Purposeful

In the early stages of a business, survival can take up most of the owner’s attention. There are bills to pay, children to raise, employees to support, and a constant need to secure the next project. Those pressures underscored the early years of Big Fish. Hard work and long hours were necessary to provide for the people depending on the company.

As the business matured, the focus began to shift. Growth became less about simply completing more jobs and more about creating meaningful work, supporting families, improving the homeowner experience, and building a company that could make the construction industry better.

That purpose can be seen across our project portfolio, but it also shows up behind the scenes. It affects how we communicate, respond to mistakes, and make decisions when no one is watching.

Experience Should Create Humility

Years in construction should produce confidence. Homeowners deserve a contractor who understands materials, installation, and the realities of working on an existing home. However, experience should also produce humility. The longer we do this work, the more clearly we see that there’s always something to learn. 

As Erik shared, “Everything that I have I was given.” We’re immensely grateful to everyone who has supported Big Fish Contracting over the years, including the homeowners who trusted us with their projects and the team members who have supported our growth.

Some of our beliefs have not changed. We still believe in honest communication, dependable work, and treating people with care. Other methods have evolved because our team and our homeowners have taught us better ways to put those values into practice.

We expect that growth to continue. If you’re planning a roofing, siding, or remodeling project and want a team that will bring both experience and an open mind to the conversation, contact Big Fish Contracting to get started.